Proof that the Electrons are not Matter.

Project Gutenberg EPUB3 edition H. Stanley Redgrove
Open passage
§ 80. This eminent physicist, however, had shown mathematically that a charged particle moving with a very high velocity (approaching that of light) would exhibit an appreciable increase in mass or inertia due to the charge, the magnitude of such inertia depending on the velocity of the particle. This was experimentally verified by Kaufmann, who determined the velocities, and the ratios between the electrical charge and the inertia, of various kathode particles and similar particles which are emitted by compounds of radium (see §§ 89 and 90). Sir J. J. Thomson calculated these values on the assumption that the inertia of such particles is entirely of electrical origin, and thereby obtained values in remarkable agreement with the experimental. There is, therefore, no reason for supposing the corpuscle to be matter at all; indeed, if it were, the above agreement would not be obtained. As Professor Jones says: “Since we know things only by their properties, and since all the properties of the corpuscle are accounted for by the electrical charge associated with it, why assume that the corpuscle contains anything but the electrical charge? It is obvious that there is no reason for doing so.
Open passage
“The corpuscle is, then, nothing but a disembodied electrical charge, containing nothing material, as we have been accustomed to use that term. It is electricity, and nothing but electricity. With this new conception a new term was introduced, and, now, instead of speaking of the corpuscle we speak of the electron.”[96] Applying this modification to the above view of the constitution of matter, we have what is called “the electronic theory,” namely, that the material atoms consist of electrons, or units of electricity in rapid motion; which amounts to this—that matter is simply an electrical phenomenon.

Source notes

Open passage
[96]H. C. Jones: The Electrical Nature of Matter and Radioactivity (1906), p. 21.

Source attribution

Alchemy: Ancient and Modern, Project Gutenberg eBook #43240

The Corpuscular Theory of Matter. The Electronic Theory of Matter.